Two Pulitzer Prize-winning authors, Robert Samuels and Toluse Olorunnipa, were silenced and prevented from discussing systemic racism at an event in Tennessee. The authors, known for their outstanding book, “His Name Is George Floyd,” were disallowed from reading their own work to students and engaging in conversations about racism, raising questions about the state’s stance on race-related discussions in educational settings.
Tennessee’s troubling trend
Just two days before the scheduled event at Whitehaven High School in Memphis, organisers imposed a ban on Samuels and Olorunnipa, leaving them unable to share their powerful narrative with the students. The restrictions went beyond just preventing them from discussing systemic racism; they also prohibited the authors from distributing copies of their book on George Floyd to the students, further limiting the exposure of vital narratives.
“I was thinking about the great disservice that they’re giving these students who deserve better.”
Robert Samuels, “His Name Is George Floyd” co-author
Samuels expressed his disappointment, saying, “I was thinking about the great disservice that they’re giving these students who deserve better.” He added, “I thought about my personal disappointment and feelings of naïveté that despite all the work Tolu and I had done to make sure the book would be written in a way that was accessible to them, a larger system decided that they were going to take it away.”
The event, organised by Memphis Reads, a community reading programme affiliated with Christian Brothers University, was intended to provide an opportunity for the authors to connect with Black students and share their personal stories. However, the organisers were caught between the authors and the constraints imposed by Tennessee’s book-banning laws and restrictions on discussing race-related topics.
Read: Scholastic backtracks after alleged exclusion of diverse books
The authors had initially planned the event in collaboration with Justin Brooks, the director of the university’s Center for Community Engagement. While Brooks conveyed the restrictions to the authors, they did not have direct communication with the school district. According to event organisers, the school district provided guidance on adhering to Tennessee’s laws, but the extent of the restrictions led to a contentious situation.
Whitehaven High School and the Memphis-Shelby County Schools district are predominantly Black, making this incident even more troubling. Despite this, school district officials denied that they had restricted what the authors could discuss or read to the students. They did, however, prohibit the distribution of the book, citing a lengthy review process as the reason, as reported by NBC News.
Memphis Reads, which selects books each year that engage the community in relevant societal issues, chose “His Name Is George Floyd” as a fitting selection. The book sheds light on how a simple desire to breathe turned into a global movement after a viral video in 2020 captured the tragic death of George Floyd at the hands of a White former Minneapolis police officer, Derek Chauvin.
Statewide battle for academic freedom
The incident in Memphis is not an isolated one. It reflects a broader trend seen in school districts across the nation, where discussions about racism, diversity, and inclusion are being curtailed or silenced altogether. Tennessee, in particular, has been in the spotlight for passing legislation that grants the state control over school book offerings and allows local school boards to veto and modify curriculum decisions. These actions have drawn sharp criticism from advocates of free speech and intellectual freedom, including the Nashville Public Library, which launched a “Freedom to Read” campaign.
In 2021, Governor Bill Lee signed a law restricting what public school teachers can discuss concerning racism, white privilege, and unconscious bias, further fueling the debate over the extent of permissible discourse in educational settings.
The incident at Whitehaven High School serves as a stark reminder of the ongoing struggle to foster open and inclusive discussions about race and racism in American classrooms, even as the nation grapples with issues of equity and justice. It highlights the need for continued advocacy for free speech and a comprehensive understanding of history and society.