Author J D Barker has issued an apology following a controversial marketing pitch for his upcoming novel, which sparked widespread criticism and led to his agent severing ties with him. The incident centres around an email sent to high-profile BookTok influencers, predominantly young women, inviting them to create “racy” sponsored content to promote Barker’s new book.
Controversial marketing pitch sparks backlash in BookTok community
The contentious email, dispatched on January 23rd by the PR firm BestOfBookTok and signed by “Julia,” promoted Barker’s “sexually charged dark thriller,” titled “Behind a Closed Door.” The email outlined a payment structure based on follower count and encouraged influencers to be creative, suggesting that the content should align with the “spicy” nature of the book. Some proposed ideas included provocative uses of the book in videos.
JD Barker released a statement via email – i can’t find it on his social media accounts – claiming the message was sent by a PR firm. But he’s one of the founders of the PR firm…
— kelsey weekman (@kelsaywhat) January 26, 2024
(screenshots from by_the_bookcase on threads) pic.twitter.com/h7MnRjuUBG
This approach, however, was met with immediate backlash from the BookTok community. Influencers expressed their discomfort and dismay, condemning the pitch as “predatory” and “creepy.” Such strong reactions were not just confined to social media platforms; the professional repercussions for Barker were swift and significant.
@booksofaginger I am BEGGING authors to use PR companies if they want to interact with book influencers for promo as these kind of emails are predatory, creepy, and downright offensive to receive. Why would i ever want to promote an author who thinks the only way i can do it is by means like this? #authorsbehavingbadly #authorsoftiktok #authorsofbooktok #booktok #bookish #bookishthoughts #bookishtiktok #bookthoughts #bookopinions #bookishopinions #bookdiscussion #booksofaginger #booktoker #bookproblems #bookpromo #bookishcontent #bookishcontentcreator #bookcommunity #bookishcommunity
♬ original sound – Siân | Booktok
Alec Shane of Writers House, Barker’s now-former agent, expressed his dismay over the situation. “I no longer represent J D Barker and am upset and saddened by what has transpired,” Shane told Publishers Weekly. Furthermore, Barker’s website has since removed the contact information for Shane and the Authors Unbound speakers bureau, signalling a clear severance of their professional relationship.
Read: Author Cait Corrain loses book deal over secret review bombing
The controversy deepened with revelations about Barker’s connection to BestOfBookTok, a firm he co-founded, raising questions about his initial denial of involvement in the email’s creation. In a follow-up correspondence, Barker claimed the email was sent without his approval, a statement contradicted by his affiliation with the PR firm.
Author J D Barker apologises amid professional fallout and community outcry
On January 23rd, an email went out on my behalf to known BookTok influencers without consideration of age or gender, from a company I own, detailing the framework of a social media marketing campaign meant to promote my upcoming novel, Behind A Closed Door; an erotic thriller set…
— J.D. Barker (@jdbarker) January 26, 2024
In response to the growing backlash, Barker reached out to Publishers Weekly, offering an apology and accepting full responsibility, but stopped short of approving the email. He regretted the oversight that led to its distribution without a necessary rewrite, acknowledging the hurt caused to the recipients. “I have nothing but respect for the writing community and the people who champion it and I’ve let all of you down. I have nothing but the deepest respect for women,” Barker stated.
“The email wasn’t meant to go out without a substantial rewrite, but through a chain of errors, it did. I take full responsibility for that […] I deeply regret the hurt I’ve caused to those who received it. I have nothing but respect for the writing community and the people who champion it and I’ve let all of you down. I have nothing but the deepest respect for women.”
J D Barker
This incident has sparked a broader discussion within the BookTok community and the literary world at large about the ethics of marketing practices and the importance of respecting the boundaries and demographics of influencer communities. Barker’s full statement is available for public viewing, as the community continues to process the implications of this marketing misstep.